SteakandKidneyPie's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Auto-Tuna Fish]

Meh

This was quite basic, the only movement that was involved was the transition for the tuna and the lip synching. Quite basic. The song wasn't even that great and the comedy was very poor.

I know you all can animate well so try involve movement and a bit more animation.

5/10

5/5, very generously

Pjorg responds:

Quite basic.

[Violet Kold]

Hey dude

I reccomend you re-submit this another day. Once you have had a stuff up, people blam it. If you re-submit this you will get so many more views because this great collab has potential to be frontpaged.

Anyway, the art is great, keep it up

CloudEater responds:

ye cool

[Snowballs]

Well done

The animation was great as well as the comedy, though it could have been a tad longer and the voice could have been better but as you said a while back, your mic broke so there is no need to deduct a point.

Great work and I would love to see more

psychicpebbles responds:

haha im glad u liked it

[Naudhiz]

Woot

Bloody well done Marsume, you are getting so much better. I can not wait until you realease the actual video. Please, whatever you do just keep on creating episodes and go mad with your animation.

10/10 animation
10/10 sound
10/10 voice
10/10 music
10/10 theme
10/10 storyline
10/10 awesome

Marsume responds:

:O Thanks man!

[Triangle n' Octagon 2]

Very lame

The reason for this high rating is because you are a popular user. The comedy is alright but the animation is not your best. This is a lot like number one though.

Anyway, hopefully you improve the next one.

JohnnyUtah responds:

here we go again.

look everybody, I'm getting knocked down a few pegs by the flash police.

[The Carbonwater Show ep.6]

Good

This is something different and entertaining. I like these kind of animations that do not take up too much megabyte and go for a while. The only thing that should be improved is the walk cycle, but that is probably just the style you have given these characters.

Anyway, the voices need to be the same volume. It is a pain having to turn up the sound to here different voices.

Hope to see more though, you have all done an excellent job especially you CarbonWater.

Also, why did you call it the carbonwater show?

Carbonwater responds:

I couldn't decide on a decent name for the show.
It's a show that I made, so why not name it after myself? Makes sense to me.

Plus it'll be a plot point for much later in the series.

[Joey n' Glenn 2]

Not Bad

Though you need better animation/voices instead of using speakonia.

Anyway, it was something different and I would like to see another one, only improved.

7 / 10

5/5 for the sake

Gustavos responds:

To be honest, I don't know where this series is going. If the episodes should all look moderately terrible, if the voices should always be Speakonia instead of us. Right now, we still need to define "quality spam". And if these are meant to entertain the random viewer rather than just us.

We'll figure it out. These are meant to be fun to make, after all. :)

[Oney's Birffday Bash]

Really Good

Though there was room for improvement. But for the time period this was created in, you guys didn't do too bad.

My least favourite was probably AlmightyHans, but I know he had to do it in a very short time

psychicpebbles responds:

He was also super busy.

His part was my fav.